Chapter 3
The Hundredth Ji Gong
The copycat phenomenon had a season, the way everything in this city has a season, and the season was the spring of the year the trial was scheduled, and it began with a market.
I saw the first one on a Saturday, in the open-air market off the lower road, where the vendors sell vegetables and socks and cheap kitchen knives and the air smells of wet cardboard and frying oil. A man of about forty in a brown robe was standing over a woman whose crate of oranges had tipped, and he was picking the oranges up one by one and putting them back in the crate, and he was doing it slowly, and he was doing it with a camera on him. Two men with a phone on a gimbal stood at the edge of the frame. The woman was saying, in the flat voice of a person who has been made part of a video without being asked, “It’s all right, it’s all right, thank you, thank you.” And the man in the robe picked up the last orange, and turned to the camera, and said, “Compassion is not a performance. It is a practice.” And then he did it again, because the light was wrong.
I watched from behind a stall that sold plastic buckets. I was not on an order; it was my day off, or as close to a day off as a rider has, and I had come to the market to buy socks, three pairs for ten yuan. And I stood there with the socks in my hand and felt the thing I had started to feel every time I saw a copy, which is not anger and not jealousy but a kind of vertigo, the feeling of a man watching his own reflection walk into a room he is already standing in and do everything wrong.
The crowd was eating it. That is the thing to understand about the counterfeit economy. The crowd knew. Everyone in that market knew that the man in the robe was doing it for the camera, and everyone watched anyway, because the doing-for-the-camera and the doing were, in the market’s arithmetic, the same act, and because a good deed performed on camera still leaves oranges in a crate. The woman got her oranges back. The man got his clip. The platform got its engagement. There was no loser in the transaction that anyone could point to, and that is exactly what made it intolerable.
I did not confront him. I want to be honest about that, because there is a version of this book in which I walk up to the man in the robe and pull off his mask and the crowd applauds, and that version is a lie. I bought my socks. I went home. The clip got two million views by evening, and the caption called him “one of the city’s Ji Gongs,” and three days later the same account posted an advertisement for a “merit fan” — fifteen yuan, three for forty — and the man in the robe was in the advertisement, holding the fan, smiling.
That was Lai San. I met him properly two weeks later, because I went looking for him, and that decision is the first one I regret in this book.
He operated out of a second-floor office above a phone-repair stall on the old commercial street, with a desk and a fake plant and a wall of certificates in red seals, and a sign on the door that said 济公法律援助 — Ji Gong Legal Aid: We Fight For You. He was thirty-eight, with a belly and a gold chain and the cheerful hopeless face of a man who has never once been embarrassed in his life. He offered me tea. He offered me a job. He offered me, by the end of the conversation, a share of the franchise, because he did not recognize me, and because he recognized me, and because I have never been able to tell which it was.
“Let me ask you something,” he said, when I told him I was a rider and not a customer. “You’ve seen the video. The original. The drunk in the alley. What did you think?”
“I thought he was trying to help a girl,” I said.
“Correct. And did he profit?”
“No.”
“Exactly.” He poured the tea, badly. “And what did he get for his trouble? Two broken ribs, a suspension, a debt collector, and a fan. The man is a fool. A noble fool. I respect him. But a fool. You know what I get for helping a woman with her oranges? A million views and a fan contract. Who did more for the woman? Me. I put her oranges back and I made her the most famous orange-seller in the district. The fool put his body between a girl and four men and got nothing. Which of us is the better Ji Gong?”
“You’re not a Ji Gong,” I said.
“I’m a franchise,” he said, and smiled, and drank his tea, and did not spill a drop, which I somehow resented more than anything else he did.
His “legal aid” was what I suspected and worse. He took calls from creditors — small creditors, men like Ma-ge before Ma-ge was bought — and he “mediated” debts for a fee, and his men did the “mediation.” He used the monk’s face on his business cards and the four-character song in his hold music and the colour gold in every surface of the room. He told me he had never read a sutra and did not intend to. He told me the word compassion the way other men tell a joke they have told too often. And when I got up to leave, he said the sentence that I have turned over more than any other sentence of that spring.
“You know why it works?” he said. “Because the city doesn’t want a hero. It wants a service. A hero makes you feel guilty. A service takes the guilt away. I am the guilt-taking-away business. And the fool in the alley is my supplier. He supplies the guilt. I take it away. That is the whole economy. You can be angry at me, but I am not the one who made the market.”
I left without putting my cup down properly. I still think about that. I did not even thank him for the tea.
Aguang came to me twice more before he died.
The first time was at the temple, on a Sunday, when he came to the courtyard with his cardboard fan and stood in front of the arhat hall, holding the fan the way you hold something at a shrine. He had come to be near the source, I think — not me, the source, the place where the story had begun, the hall of five hundred statues where a drunk had once woken up. He did not know that the drunk had been me. He did not know that he had asked me on the Trail and that I had lied to him, or he did know and had decided not to mind. He bowed to the arhats. He bowed to the abbot’s jar. He put a packet of instant noodles in the donation box, because it was all he had, and the novice looked at him and did not know what to do, and accepted it.
I was sweeping. He saw me and came over, and this time he did not ask if I was him. He asked me whether I thought it was true, the old story, the one about the monk who broke every rule and healed people anyway. He asked it seriously, the way a young man asks a question he has already answered. I told him it was a story, that stories are how people carry things, and that carrying a thing is good if it does not break your back.
He said, “My sister says the same thing. She says I’m sweet and stupid. She’s fifteen.” He laughed. “But I think if nobody’s the fool, then nothing ever changes. Somebody has to be the fool first.”
I should have said something better than what I said. I said, “Be careful.” He said he would. And then he asked me — because he was a boy of nineteen and I was a man in a rider’s jacket and we were the same shape — whether I thought it was a mistake to keep the fan in his jacket. I said the fan was not a shield. I said the fan was a thing you hold. And he looked at me with the great, terrible, open face of someone who has decided to be kind and is asking only for permission, and he said, “I know. But it helps.”
The second time was the night he died. I did not see him. I only learned where he was, afterward, from a boy with a radio.
It was the first days of the third month. I was on the far side of the river, out in Nan’an, on a cash run to a hotpot restaurant that paid me to beat the bridge. It was a Thursday, and the night was warm for the first time that year, and the fog had lifted, and the city was out, and every street had its tables and its lights and its smoke and its noise.
At half past ten my radio, which was clipped to my shirt under the jacket, clicked twice. That was Yaoji’s code for come in.
“Go ahead,” I said.
“Are you sitting down,” he said. His voice had the flatness it gets when he is reading something he does not want to read.
“No.”
“There’s a thing happening at the night market on the lower road. A man with a knife. Someone says it’s a domestic. Someone says it’s a debt. There’s a kid in a yellow jacket there. He’s got a fan.”
I was already moving. I am setting it in the record that I was already moving, because it is the only part of what happened that I can defend. I had the scooter turned around before he finished the sentence and I went across the bridge without paying attention to the lights, which I have never done before or since, and I have run the arithmetic of that ride a thousand times and the arithmetic always comes out the same. The night market on the lower road was nine kilometers from where I stood, across the river and up the hill, and at that hour with the traffic it was a twenty-minute ride if the bridge was clear, and the bridge was not clear, and it took me twenty-six minutes.
Yaoji kept the channel open. That was against the protocol and he did it anyway. Somewhere around the fourteenth minute he said, “There’s a video. Someone’s streaming it. I’ll turn it on. Don’t watch it.”
I did not watch it then. I watched it later, like everyone else, many times, and I am going to describe it plainly because I promised the reader the receipts. The clip is ninety-four seconds long. In the first eleven seconds, a man is holding a kitchen knife on a woman at a folding table outside a skewer stall, and the woman is crying, and the stall owner is backing away with his hands up. In the twelfth second, a young man in a yellow jacket walks into the frame from the left. He is holding a fan made of cardboard and packing tape. He raises it, the way you raise a thing at a shrine, and he says something that the audio does not catch. In the sixteenth second, the man with the knife turns. In the eighteenth second, the man with the knife moves, once, and the boy in the yellow jacket comes down hard against the corner of the skewer stall and then onto the ground. In the nineteenth second, the boy’s hand opens and the fan comes apart and the cardboard blows off down the street, and it is on the ground in the foreground of the clip for the rest of the video, a little dark shape nobody steps on. In the twentieth second, the crowd starts. There are, by the count of the later report, between forty and eighty people in the alley and at the mouth of it. In the twenty-first second, the first phone goes up. In the forty-fourth second, someone says the word ambulance, and in the fifty-first second someone else finally calls one. In the seventy-eighth second, the man with the knife runs. In the ninetieth second, the boy on the ground is alone in the middle of a ring of people, and one woman kneels down beside him, and the rest of the ring is still holding their phones up, because the algorithm had already decided, and the algorithm is faster than any of us.
The paramedics took eleven minutes. The boy was bleeding from a wound that a doctor later said would have been survivable with pressure applied in the first three minutes, and no one in the crowd applied pressure, because everyone assumed someone else was already doing it, and because a phone in your hand is the enemy of a hand on a wound. He died in the ambulance at 11:14 p.m., at the age of nineteen, six kilometers from the hospital that his mother had been born in.
I reached the alley at 11:06. The ambulance had already come. The skewer stall was closed. The ring was gone. There was a dark patch on the pavement and a folding stool on its side and, near the wall, in the drain, a piece of yellow cardboard with packing tape on it, which a woman with a broom was trying to sweep into the gutter. I knelt down and took it out of the drain before she could. It was the better half of the fan, the half with the handle, and the handle was wrapped in tape where a boy had held it, and the tape had gone dark with the water of the drain, and I put it in my jacket pocket and I sat down on the curb with it, and the fog came back up off the river and did what the fog does.
The city’s feed had the video up for three days. On the first day it was the coronavirus of compassion; on the second day it was a pengci gone wrong; on the third day it was a policy question. On the fourth day it was gone, because something else happened somewhere else, and the news cycle in this city has a memory of about seventy-two hours, which is the most honest measure of a culture I have ever found.
The comment I remember best was on the third day. It said: he died because a story taught him the fan was a shield. It had four likes. The comment below it said: what story. there’s no story. there’s just a guy. It had forty thousand.
They asked me for his name eleven days later, a woman with a clipboard and a form, in a small office with a poster about traffic safety. I told her I did not know it. I told her I had never learned it, though I had stood on a trail with him and he had told me the way to Nanjimen. She wrote witness does not know victim on the form, and asked me to sign it, and I signed it, and the signature went into a file, and the file went into a cabinet, and the cabinet would be opened in a courtroom in the autumn, and the not-knowing of a name would be read out by a man in a grey suit to prove something about the kind of man I am.
The boy’s name was Aguang. His family name I learned from his sister, who found me through the rider network, and I am not going to put it in this book, because she asked me not to. He was nineteen. He had a phone background of a monk on a hoverboard, which is the counterfeit the market had made of me, and a sister of fifteen, and a debt he was paying down, and a favorite noodle order — pickled beans, extra chili, no egg — and a confidence that the world was the sort of place where a person with a fan could stand in front of a knife and be seen.
I did not go to the funeral. I want to say why, and then I am going to stop mentioning it, because the book is going to keep coming back to it whether I want it to or not. I did not go because I was afraid that the city would film me at the funeral, and that the clip would be captioned the real Ji Gong mourns his imitator, and that the boy’s sister would have to live in a story about a man she had never met. So I did not go. Wang Niangniang went, with a condolence envelope and a bowl of the aunties’ noodles, and she sat with the family for the whole vigil, and she reported back to the tunnel that the sister was dry-eyed and furious and had asked whether anyone from the temple was coming. And I sat in the tunnel with the piece of yellow cardboard in my pocket and the note on the shelf and the gourd of tea on the table, and I understood the second half of the couplet for the first time not as a warning I had been given, but as a bill I had already been charged.
If the world imitates me, it walks into the demon’s path.
The world had imitated me. The world had walked into the demon’s path. And the world was a nineteen-year-old boy with a cardboard fan, lying on the pavement of a night market, under a sky full of phones.