THE PAINTED SKIN
☰

Chapter 9

The Shift

The second skinless body was a woman named Jennifer Okafor, and it was the name that broke the pattern open.

She was twenty-six, a first-generation Nigerian-American nurse, and she had worked the same floor at the General as the woman Zhang kept seeing in the second-floor window of Duboce Triangle. She had gone missing on a Sunday and been found on a Thursday in a stairwell near Civic Center, arranged, flayed, her face gone.

Renner spread the photographs on the table in the Homicide annex as a man spreads a losing hand — all of them, face up, so nothing could hide. The first flayed woman had been white: a gallery owner from the Marina. The second was white too: a tech worker from Noe Valley. The third, they had thought, would follow, because for two terrible weeks the pattern had seemed to be white women, and a pattern, once you see it, is a comfort even when it is a horror, because it promises to hold.

Jennifer Okafor was not white.

There was more to it. She had not been chosen for what she was. She had been chosen for what she looked like, or rather for what a man looking at her would see, and the man looking at her, in the week before she vanished, had been a white man in the Marina whose search history, when Renner’s people pulled it, was a long quiet catalogue of a particular kind of want. The ghost had not gone to the Marina for Jennifer. The ghost had gone for the man, and Jennifer had been the face she borrowed to get to him.

“So the pattern’s not white women,” Renner said.

“No,” Zhang said slowly. “The pattern is changing.”

He had been reading the lore for weeks, as he had not let himself read it in years, and the pieces had begun to arrange themselves into a shape he did not want. The huapi gui did not choose at random. She read her prey. She read what he reached for, gave it to him, and then fed.

“The first women were white because she was learning,” Zhang said. “Because the men she hunts — the ones whose hearts she wants — most of them want a white face. But not all of them.” He looked up. “She has been reading them. Their phones. Their histories. The way they look at women on the street. And she has found what a lot of them actually want.”

Renner was very still. “Say it.”

“An Asian face.”

The room was quiet. Through the thin wall a phone rang and rang and no one answered it.

“So the question the papers keep asking,” Renner said, flat, “‘why did the bodies change’ — the answer is she found the most effective face and switched.”

“Yes.”

“And the next women she takes will be Asian.”

“Yes. And the next man she opens will be a white man who wanted one.”

They looked at each other across the table, and Zhang saw the moment Renner understood that the pattern was not a comfort but a weapon, and that one end of it was aimed slowly at every man in the city who carried a certain quiet want in his pocket — including, perhaps, the man across the table.

“Then we find the men,” Renner said. “Before she does.”

“Or we find her first, and make her face us.”

Zhang did not say what he was thinking, because it would have sounded like a confession. He was thinking that he had spent his adult life building faces for a machine, the same way the men on Eidolon’s floor built faces, the same way the app built faces, the same way the thing in the city built faces, and that he had told himself the whole time that his work was clean, that a face reduced to a loss function could not be used the way a living face could. The mathematics did not care. The mathematics was a tool, and the tool did not know whether it was reconstructing a missing person or painting a fantasy, and the city was full of men who would use it for the second and never ask what it was for. He had known that, and gone on working, and the work had stayed clean only because he had refused to look at what it was for. The ghost had looked. The ghost had looked at the whole machine — the apps, the faces, the wanting — and seen it for what it was, and turned it into a weapon. And the men the weapon was aimed at were the men who had built the machine.

It happened to Renner before either of them was ready, on the fourth night.

Zhang had taken to walking the detective to his car in the structure under Bryant, a small escort neither of them acknowledged, and he had pressed a folded fu into Renner’s palm that first week, written in his own hand now, the cinnabar fresh and wrong against the gray world of the man who carried it. Renner had taken it and looked at it and not thrown it away, which Zhang had learned to read as a man’s whole confession.

She was waiting by the car.

Zhang felt her before he saw her — the xieqi, the bloom of it at the edge of his sight, and the air on the concrete level gone the way air goes before a storm. He said Renner’s name, and Renner stopped, and the overhead light over the far stairwell died, and then she was there, standing beside the sedan, wearing a face neither of them had seen. An Asian face, young, the face of a woman whose body was probably even now being found in some stairwell across town.

She looked at Renner. Not at Zhang.

“A cop,” she said, and her voice was the low voice, and under it another voice. “You all came back for me once. A hundred years ago, in the alley. You came to rescue me.”

Renner’s hand was on his sidearm and it was shaking, and Zhang saw that the detective understood, with his body if not his mind, what was being offered to him.

She took one step toward him. Zhang was between them before he knew he had moved, the taomu jian out, the zhou already rising, and the air thickened, and she stopped — not at the sword but at the fu in Renner’s palm, the little folded paper that had begun, impossibly, to smoke. She gnashed her teeth at it. She did not cross.

“Next time,” she said, to Renner and to Renner alone. “You’ll come to me. They always do.”

And she was gone, and the light came back on, and Renner stood with his back against the car and the smoking fu in his hand and a face Zhang had not seen on him before — the face of a man who had spent twenty years believing in nothing and had just been handed the one belief he had not asked for.

“I’m in her file,” Renner said. His voice was steady as a voice is steady when there is nothing left to fear for. “Good. That means she can find me, and I can find her, and either way it ends.”

Zhang did not tell him that the fu would not hold forever, or that the next time she came she would wear the face of whatever Renner wanted, or that a white man and a cop was the first and last shape on her list. He only walked him the rest of the way to the car and stood in the empty structure and watched the taillights climb toward the street, and understood that the investigation had become a hunt, and that he was now the only thing standing between the ghost and every man in the city too proud to run.