THE PAINTED SKIN
☰

Chapter 12

Grace Li

The memorial was in a rented room in the Mission, because Grace Li was twenty-five and had no family in the country and the company did not want the funeral on its premises, so her friends rented a room and put photographs on a folding table and tried to make the word gone mean something.

There were flowers from a corner store, wilting in plastic. A projector that did not work, and a laptop on a chair playing a slideshow of her face — Grace at a birthday, Grace on a hike, Grace at the kitchenette making coffee with her back to the camera, caught the way you catch people you do not know you are losing. Her roommate, Ana, stood by the table and told the room, in a voice that kept threatening to break and did not, that Grace had been saving to bring her mother over from Guangzhou, and that the money was still in the account, and that she did not know what to do with it. Nobody did. The room was full of people who did not know what to do with it.

I went because I had known her a little, and because not going would have been an absence people remember. I stood in the back with the others who had known her a little, and looked at the photographs, and thought about the last thing she had said to me, months ago, in the kitchenette, when she showed me the direct messages on her phone and laughed the way people laugh to keep from crying.

They don’t even see you, she had said. That’s the thing. They look right at you and they’re looking at something else. At a shape. At an idea of what you are. And you’re supposed to be flattered.

She said it without anger, and I made a sympathetic noise and went back to my desk, and I did not think about it again until now, standing in a rented room with her face on a loop, because a man somewhere had looked at her and seen a shape and an idea and wanted it.

I had wanted it. That was the sentence I could not get out of my chest. Not me, not Theo, not for Grace — but the shape of it, the machinery of it, the wanting that flattens a person into a thing. I had run that machinery. I was running it still. The auditor’s table was in my head, predominant profile attribute: ethnicity, and Grace Li’s face was on the table, and the two things were the same thing, and I could not make them separate, and I was not sure I deserved to.

There was a memory I kept returning to, and it was not a real memory so much as a moment I had been present for without being in. Grace had come to my desk once, a month after she started, to ask about a tool the face team used. I answered her without looking up. She stood there a beat longer than the answer needed, waiting for the thing new people wait for when they are trying to be seen, and I did not give it to her. I went back to my screen, and after a moment she went back to her desk. A nothing. A half-minute in a long year. Now it was the thing I could not put down, because the not-looking was the whole of it. It was the same not-looking I did to Mina. It was the same not-looking that had been done to Grace her whole life, by every man who looked at her and saw a type. I had not killed her. I knew I had not killed her. But I could no longer find the clean line between looking away from a woman and what happens, downstream, when enough men look away for long enough.

Mina found me at the back of the room. She had come because she had been on shift when the news broke, and because she knew some of the nurses who knew Grace’s roommate, and because Mina came to these things the way she came to everything — showing up.

She stood beside me without speaking for a while, and we watched the slideshow go around again, and I was aware, as I was always aware now, of the distance between us, which was not the distance of two people who had grown apart but the distance of two people between whom a secret sits like a third person. She had stopped asking me what was wrong. That was the worst of it — not the asking, which I had learned to deflect, but the stopping, which meant she had decided the truth was something I would either say or not, and that she could not keep standing in the doorway of it forever.

“You okay?” she said.

“Yeah,” I said, and she looked at me the way she had been looking at me for weeks, and I saw, in her face, that she had stopped believing the small lies and was only waiting for the big one.

“I have to tell you something,” I said.

The words were out before I decided to say them, and they hung between us like a held breath, and I saw the thing move across her face that I had been dreading — the hope, the fear, a woman bracing for the sentence that will change everything.

I wanted to say it. In that rented room with a dead woman’s face on a loop and Mina’s whole unguarded attention on me, I wanted to empty the drawer and let her see what was in it, and for one long second I was closer to it than I had ever been, and I could feel the shape of the truth in my mouth, and I understood that this was a door I could still open, that the only thing between me and the truth was my own hand on the latch.

Before I could say it, my phone buzzed. Once. Then again.

I did not look. I made myself not look. But Mina’s eyes dropped to my pocket, and the held breath went out of her.

“It’s her, isn’t it,” she said. Not a question.

The door I had almost opened closed, and I felt it close, and I knew I would never be that close again. The truth had been one word away, and I had let a phone in my pocket take it from me, and Mina had watched it happen.

I looked at my phone, because I was a coward and because the wanting was stronger than the shame, and I read the three words on the screen, and the room with the photographs and the candles and the word gone went very far away.

Come now, Lena had written. Or I’ll find someone else.

I read it again, and the cruelty of it — the casual, practiced cruelty of a thing that knew exactly what it was withholding and exactly what the withholding would do to me — should have broken the spell, and it did not, and the not-breaking was the worst thing I had ever learned about myself. I had stood in a room with a dead woman’s face and a living woman’s love and still, at the bottom, wanted to be chosen. The wanting had never been about Lena. It had never been about any of them. It had been about the being-wanted, the being-chosen, the small electric proof that I was real, and I had spent my whole life mistaking that proof for a person, and now the proof was on my phone in three words, and I was going to answer it, because a man who has spent his life mistaking a reflection for a face does not stop reaching for the reflection just because someone has finally held up a mirror.

I looked at Mina. She was watching me, and her face was the face of a woman who had just watched a man choose, in real time, the thing that was going to destroy him, and who had known, before he did, which way he would choose.