Chapter 32
The Bodhisattva Complex
By the time the police reached the atrium, the fog had begun to settle, and what it settled on was a golden room full of dropped phones.
The phones were the thing I remember most. Two thousand people had run, and almost everyone had run with one hand up, and when the smoke-control fans finally cleared the air a little, the marble floor and the tables and the water-pit were covered in a thin layer of dropped screens, most of them still filming. The report counts four hundred and eleven. The court exhibit keeps three. Every one of the phones was a small dark eye on the floor of the atrium, and every one of them had caught some fraction of the truth, and that is the actual condition of this city, and the book is not going to pretend otherwise.
I have one more thought about the fall and it is about the workers, because the workers are the ones who had to carry the water out.
There were eleven men on the night shift at the Tower, and they were the ones who did not run. They were the electricians and the cleaners and the kitchen porters and the security guards, and they were in the building when the atrium went white, and they did what workers do in this city, which is they kept the building standing while the rich people left. They opened the fire doors and they killed the escalators and they found a woman under a table and carried her out on a loading board, and then they went down into the water-pit with a rope and pulled two men out of it, one of them alive. Nobody filmed them.
The fifty videos are all pointed at the golden Buddha and the scaffold and the VIP box, because that is where the story was, and the story was not the men with the rope. I have found three of them since. One is back at the Tower. One took a job in a hospital kitchen. The third would not speak to me, because he did not want his name to be part of the year.
I have decided to respect that. So the year’s last sentence about the night is this instead: the city that ate the man in the lane and the monk in the courtyard was also, at the same hour, in the same building, carrying a stranger up a ladder out of the water, and both things are true, and the book is not going to choose between them.
The officer who came up to me on the floor of the atrium did not arrest me and did not thank me, and both of those were correct.
“You’re the man in the robe,” he said.
“Yes.”
“You were on every screen ten minutes ago. Now there’s a dead man in the water, and there’s going to be a very long investigation, and I need you to come with me and give a statement, and I need you to not disappear. If you disappear this becomes a story about a man who fled, and I don’t have time for that story.”
“I won’t disappear.”
“Good.” He wrote something. “You understand you might be charged. Trespass, at least. Incitement, possibly. There’s a crowd crush with three broken bones and a fatality in it, and the fatality is a suspect, and the crowd is your crowd. That’s going to take lawyers a year to untangle.” He looked at my burned hands. “Do you have a lawyer?”
“No.”
“Then get one. Get one tonight.” He closed his notebook. “For what it’s worth, which is nothing in a courtroom, I watched the screens. My father had a loan from a company like that. He died without paying it. I’ve been a cop for six years and I have never once been able to touch them.” He put the notebook away. “So. Statement.”
That is the whole law’s opinion on the night the tower burned, and this is the most a machine like that can give: a correct procedure, a warning about the paperwork, and one sentence of human history recorded on a personal notebook and nowhere else. The man would spend the next two years being asked by his supervisors whether he had seen the drunk on the platform, and he would say, correctly, that he had seen nothing, because by the time he arrived the only thing on the floor was water.
Tian’s evidence did not crack the umbrella by itself, and I want to be honest about the mechanism, because the version where one honest cop brings down a conglomerate is a children’s story. What cracked the umbrella was the broadcast. The ledgers were already public, and the public already had them, and when the national feed went dark at twenty fifty-eight a hundred other feeds did not, and by midnight the folders were on every platform that mattered, and by two in the morning the district office had a problem that no amount of institutional patience could absorb, which is the problem of being seen.
The company’s own lawyers were the next domino, because a lawyer’s first loyalty is to the lawyer, and by dawn the first shell had begun to fold. Tian’s file did the third thing, which was the only thing a file can do once the world is watching: it turned the archive into a warrant. She had been carrying the drawer for eleven days, and on the first of January she put it on a desk and stood there while it was read, and she was not alone, and that mattered.
Tan Hong could have walked out of the building and been on a plane by noon. I have turned that over a great deal, and I have concluded that he could not, because the one thing he could not survive was not the arrest. It was the sight of his own congregation turning to look at the screens.
The police came up the main escalator at about eleven at night, twelve of them, in a wedge, and the chairman had not moved from the stage. He had sent his people away. That is another fact from the report: at twenty fifty-five the chairman told his personal staff to leave, and they left, and he stood alone at the lectern under the golden Buddha with his little award in front of him and his own signature on every wall, and he waited.
When the officers arrived he did not resist and he did not run, and for about one minute it looked as though the end of the year’s long arithmetic was going to be a clean and ordinary thing, a man in a good jacket walking down a marble floor with his hands where they could be seen.
Then he stopped at the base of the Buddha.
I do not know what he was thinking. I have read his own account, which he wrote in detention and which the state never published and which a clerk leaked three years later, and in it he says that he wanted to look at the statue one last time. That is possible. It is also possible that he wanted the cameras, which had come back up on the drones and the mezzanine, and which were again pointed at his face, and that someone who had spent his whole life buying visibility could not bear to leave the stage invisibly. Both readings are available. I am not going to settle it, and neither is the report.
The Buddha had a maintenance scaffold. It had been in place for the consecration, a lattice of steel around the statue’s shoulders and head, twenty meters above the atrium floor, with a small service platform at the twelfth-floor level and a ladder of gold-painted rungs up the statue’s back. The chairman walked to the base of it and began to climb. The officers called to him.
He did not answer and he did not hurry. He climbed the gold rungs in his good jacket, one at a time, like a man going up to fix a light, and the whole atrium of police and staff and the surviving guests stood on the floor and watched him go, because nobody had a protocol for a man climbing his own god in a burning building.
There is one more thing to say about the fall, and it is not about the legal reading or the theological reading. It is about the room.
I have listened to the fifty videos more than once. What the videos capture, which the report does not and the court does not, is the sound the atrium made when he stepped onto the platform. Eleven hundred people, and it went quiet. Not gradually.
In the space of about two seconds, a room that had been the loudest place in the municipality went down to a hum, and the hum was not fear and it was not grief. It was the sound of a crowd watching a man and understanding, all at once, that a decision was being made. That is what a crowd can do, it is the last thing I will ever say in defense of crowds.
It can tell the difference between an accident and an act, without being given the facts, from the shape of a single body on a single platform. The report says he slipped. Eleven hundred people stood on that golden floor with their phones up and watched him climb his own god in his own good jacket, and not one of them believed it was an accident, and every one of them was watching anyway.
I have gone back and forth about whether that is a condemnation or a gift. It is neither. It is simply the truth about a city. People will not save you, and they will not look away, and both of those facts are the same fact.
The drone show went up at twenty past eleven, and this is where the accounts split, and the split is permanent. The drone show had been scheduled for the closing at midnight, the last flourish, the fu in the sky over the river. Somebody in the control room panicked and fired it early, or the show’s software ran on a timer and nobody overrode it, and a hundred and twenty lit drones rose into the fog above the atrium’s glass roof and began to spell their character for fortune over a building that was on fire in every sense except the literal one.
The drones could not be seen, because of the fog, except as a low orange glow above the glass, and the orange glow threw a moving light down through the atrium, and the moving light did the one thing that fog and gold leaf had been waiting all night to do, which made the scaffold and the gilded shoulders of the Buddha into a single flickering surface with no edge and no depth.
The report says the chairman stepped onto the service platform and slipped. The report is a document written by people who needed a cause of death that did not require a philosophy, and it uses the word slipped four times.
The gold leaf on that platform had been applied a week earlier by the same contractor whose materials had burned my teacher, and the platform was damp, because the fog had come in through the open smoke dampers, and the report’s own photographs show a footprint and a smear and a handprint on the rail. A man in leather shoes on wet gold leaf slips. That is the reading the report endorses, and it is a good reading, and it is available to anyone who looks at the photographs.
The other reading is the one the city tells, and I will not endorse it and I will not deny it, because the whole discipline of this book is that the two readings have to survive. He did not scream. Every witness agrees on that, the scream and the silence are the two things the city cannot settle, and the silence is the thing the city cannot forgive him for, because someone who falls accidentally makes a sound and a man who steps off does not.
He had spent his whole life telling the poor that suffering was compassion in a form they could not recognize. And he stepped, or he slipped, off the twelfth-floor platform of his own golden Buddha, and he fell into the consecration pit, the shallow water under the god, and he landed beside the man who had murdered for him, who was still alive in the water and could not move, and the two of them lay in the shallow water under the golden hand, and the chairman did not get up.
He died in the ambulance. The cause is a fracture of the skull and the water in his lungs, and the precise order of those two events is not recorded, and the report says accidental death, and the court says death before trial, and the city says, to this day, whatever it needs to say, and the fifty videos disagree, and I have watched all fifty and I have no answer, and I have no answer to give you.
Tan Xiao was in the VIP box. He had been in the VIP box all night, because the family always sits above, and the VIP box had its own camera, and the camera was live, and when the atrium went white and the chairman climbed the scaffold, the young man did not go down. He stood at the glass and watched his father fall.
And then he took out his phone and held it up, so that the phone was pointed at the box and at his own face and at the golden room beyond, and he streamed it, and he did not speak for the whole fall and the whole water and the whole ambulance, and his eyes did not move at all. And then, into the livestream, in the flat, gentle, meme-literate voice that had offered me a charity ambassador contract in a temple courtyard a lifetime ago, he said the sentence the whole series has been waiting for, and he said it in dialect first because he was raised in this city even if he had been educated somewhere else.
“Dajia bie xin. Ji Gong shi jia de. Wo ba ye shi jia de. Na wo geng jia yidian hao le.”
Don’t believe any of it. Ji Gong is fake. My father’s fake too. So I’ll be a little more fake.
Then he ended the stream. It was replayed four million times in the first day, and the compilation of the fifty videos ends with the frame of his face in the glass, and the editor’s note calls that frame the only entry that is not a description, and the editor is right, because the face in the glass is not a fact. It is a door, and the boy behind it had just closed his father’s coffin with both hands and had decided, in the same motion, what he was going to be for the rest of his life, and that is where Book One stops on the question of the villain, and that is where Book Two begins.
Tan Xiao’s stream was the cleanest document of the night, and that is the part that should frighten anyone who cares about this country. His father fell, and the son did not go down to the water. He held up a phone instead, and his face was in the glass, and his voice was flat, and he said that the fake and the father and the son were all fake, and he said it to four million people in the calm tone of a man reading a product update. The city, which had spent a year learning to look, looked.
It watched a boy bury his father in public and call it a livestream, and it did not look away, and by the morning the clip had a soundtrack, and by the weekend it had a parody, and by the spring it had a documentary. That is what Book Two is going to be about. Not the father, who built the machine. The son, who understood it better than the father ever did. He will run it with the manners of a man who has nothing left to lose, and he will be so much harder to see than a man on a golden platform, because he will not build a monument. He will build a feed.
I saw him once before the trial.
He was in a ward at the Third People’s, in a bed by the window, with a cage over his legs and a tube in his throat that had taken his voice and given him a whisper. There were two officers at the door. He had been under guard for six weeks. The ward smelled of disinfectant and orange peel, which is the smell of every ward in this city, and I stood at the foot of the bed with my burned hands in my pockets, and neither of us said anything for a long time.
Then he asked me, in the whisper, the question that ended our quiet war.
“When your father carried his last refrigerator — did he call out for anyone?”
I stood there for a moment. I had been carrying the answer for twenty years and I had never once been asked for it, and the man asking me was the only other man alive who had carried refrigerators up those stairs. I said, “I don’t know. I was six. Nobody ever told me.”
He looked at the ceiling for a while. Then he said, “He did. He called for his father.” And he closed his eyes, and the officers took me out, and that was the last time I ever spoke to the man who may have watched my father die. I do not know whether he was telling me the truth or giving me a gift. I have decided not to decide. That is what this book is. That is all any of us get.