Chapter 19
Chapter Nineteen
Recommendation for direct doctoral study (直博). Candidate: Huang Zhichuan, School of Environmental Science and Engineering. Recommendation: accepted by supervisor, approved by school. Candidate’s decision: ☑ declined. — form, March 2018
The recruiter came to the job fair in March and set up her banner in the hall of the engineering building: a private testing company from Shenzhen. Third-party, with a certificate on their banner and a photograph of their lab on a screen behind her.
He stood in the queue because everyone stood in the queue. When his turn came she looked at his CV for eleven seconds and asked whether he had any certificates. He said not yet.
She told him to get one—the registered safety engineer, or the EIA—and then to come back. Without it the salary was twelve, with it fifteen, plus the field allowance. The work was air, water and soil: sampling at factories, then the report. She said it in the voice of a woman who had said it four hundred times that day, and she said that the certificate was the difficult part and the sampling was not.
He asked who the reports were for. She said, “The client,” and looked up, and asked whether he wanted the job or not. He said he would think about it. She said that everyone said that, and gave him a card.
He put the card in his pocket and did not take it out again. In April he threw it away with the other cards from the fair, and the bin was full of them.
The professor’s office was on the fourth floor of the chemistry building, with a window that looked at another building.
He had been in it four times: once for the thesis topic, twice for the thesis, once for the recommendation. The fourth time was in March, after the recommendation had been approved.
The professor was in his fifties and had a good publication record and a manner that was neither warm nor cold but simply efficient, and he had been efficient about this.
The professor said that the direct line was the fastest in the country: four years, no master’s in between, a bench of his own by the second year. He said the city was good and the group was good and that the boy’s titration numbers last term had been the best in the year.
He said thank you.
The professor said the alternative was a year of examinations and applications, and then four years somewhere else with a supervisor who did not know him. He said he was not going to talk him into it. He said he was telling him what the arithmetic said.
He said he understood the arithmetic.
“Then what is the objection?”
He took the folded page out of his bag and put it on the desk: the printout, three years old now, soft at the folds, the toner gone gray.
The professor read it. Then he read it again, and turned it over, and turned it back.
“Subject thirty-seven.”
“Village three. Age eight. Sixteen point four.”
“Yours?”
“I do not know. It could be one of four boys.”
The professor put the page down on the desk and looked at it for a while the way he looked at a spectrum.
“You want to find the logbook,” he said.
“I want to find the logbook.”
“That is not a project. That is an archive.” He said it without unkindness. “The archive is in Shantou. The people who hold it are not going to give it to a student from Guangzhou with a photocopy and a theory. They have had twenty years of people coming to that town with photocopies and theories.”
“I know.”
“Then you understand why I am not going to fund it.”
He said he understood.
“You can still take the direct line and do this as a side question. A chapter. People do that.”
He said nothing. The window hummed with the air conditioning. The professor turned the pen over again and then put it down and said the thing that ended the meeting.
“Write down what you actually want. Not the project. What you want.” He pushed a pad across the desk. “One sentence.”
He wrote one sentence on the pad.
The professor read it. He did not say anything for a moment. Then he folded the sheet of paper and put it in his own drawer, which he had never done with anything else.
“Go to Shantou,” he said. “Take the entrance examination. I will write the reference.”
The train to Shantou took three hours. He had the window seat on the left, and the country went from the flat gray city to the green hills. And the hills were the same hills the bus had crossed four years ago in the other direction.
The medical campus was on the north side of the city, on a hill, with the teaching building at the top and a parking lot and a row of trees. The Department of Preventive Medicine was on the third floor of a building that had been built in the nineties and had not been changed since: a corridor of doors with name cards. A notice board with a yellowed timetable, a water dispenser with one blue bottle left.
Her door had a card with her name and her title, and under the title, in smaller characters, the words occupational and environmental health.
He knocked. A voice said come in the office was small and full. Two filing cabinets, one of them with a drawer that did not shut. A desk with a computer and a stack of journals and a mug with a chip out of the rim. A window with a view of the parking lot. On the wall, a photograph of a group of people standing in a village lane, twenty years old, faded, the faces small.
She was behind the desk, in her late thirties, with her hair pinned up and a water bottle on the desk beside her hand—a steel bottle. The kind people carried when they did not trust what came out of the tap.
She looked at him for a moment.
“You are the boy from Guiyu,” she said. “The one who has been writing letters.”
He had written four letters over eleven months. The first had been two pages. The second had been shorter. The third had not been answered. The fourth had been one page and had contained the printout, photocopied, with the row circled in pencil.
“I did not answer the fourth,” she said. “I answer about one in ten. If I answered them all I would not have time to do the work.”
He said he understood.
“Sit down.” She moved a stack of journals off the chair. “You want the cohort.”
“I want the cohort.”
“The cohort is mine. Not in the way you think—not property. In the way that I am the only one still here who knows where the files are. And half of them are in that cabinet and half of them are in boxes in a storage room. And the ethics approval for a follow-up has to come through this department, and this department does not give its data to strangers.”
He said he did not want the data given to him.
“Then what do you want?”
He took the printout out of his bag and put it on the desk.
She looked at it. Then she opened the drawer of the desk and took out a pair of reading glasses and put them on, and looked at it again.
“Thirty-seven,” she said.
“Village three. Age eight. Sixteen point four.”
She turned the page over, and then back.
“You were in the second round,” she said. “The second round took the older ones. It was the only round that took the older ones, because the kindergarten would not let us have the little ones after the first year. And the primary school would, and so we took eight-year-olds for one season and then stopped.” She took her glasses off. “I remember the eight-year-olds. They were the ones who could answer for themselves. The little ones could not.”
He asked whether she remembered the row.
“I remember the round. I do not remember the row.” She put the glasses down. “I remember the logbook. It was blue, a hard cover, and the pages were ruled, and we wrote in pencil because the pen ran in the humidity. Two of us wrote in it. I wrote the notes in the margin. The other one wrote the numbers.”
She looked at him.
“Why do you want it?”
He had prepared for this. He had a page of reasons in his bag, in the smallest characters, and he did not take it out.
“Because in twenty years nobody has followed them,” he said. “The studies took a sample, and then the sample went back to being children, and the children grew up, and nobody followed them past seven years. I have read every one. The longest was seven years and it stopped.”
“And?”
“And the town thinks it was measured and then forgotten. Which is true.” He put his hands flat on the desk. “I want to follow them. All of them, or as many as will come. Twenty years late.”
She was quiet. Outside the window a car went across the parking lot and the sound came up and went away.
“That is a thesis,” she said. “That is not a reason.”
He looked at her. She was not being cruel. She was doing what the professor had done: waiting for the sentence that was not the project.
He said the thing he had written on the pad in the professor’s office, the one sentence, the one the professor had folded and put in his drawer.
“I am not asking for the position,” he said. “I am asking for the lead.”
She looked at him a long time.
Then she took the steel bottle off the desk, unscrewed the cap, poured a little water into the chipped mug, and pushed the mug across the desk to him. Which was not tea and was not a ceremony, and was the first thing she had given anyone in that office in years.
“Drink that,” she said. “Then we will talk about the ethics committee.”
After the mug, she took him down to the basement.
It was at the end of a corridor that smelled of floor polish and old paper, and the key was on a nail behind the door of the neighbouring room. She unlocked it and turned on the light, and the light came on in two of the four tubes and flickered in a third.
The room was twelve square metres and full. Metal shelving, six bays of it, and on the shelves the cardboard boxes with the years written on the ends in marker: 2004, 2005. 2006, 2007, then a gap, then 2011, then a row of boxes marked with the names of other towns.
“Each box is one village, one round,” she said. “The forms are in the front and the samples are logged at the back. We did not keep the blood. We kept the forms and the numbers and the logbooks.”
She pulled out the 2004 box marked with the third village and set it on the floor and opened the lid. The inside smelled of dust and of the particular smell of old toner, and the papers were stacked in folders tied with string.
He looked at the folders and did not put his hand in.
“You can look at the forms,” she said. “Not the logbook. The logbook has the names in the margins, and the names are not for a student’s eyes until the ethics committee says they are.”
He said he understood.
She watched him a moment, then took out one folder and opened it and held it so he could see. A stack of consent forms, each one a single page with a thumbprint where the signature should have been, because in 2004 some of the parents could not write their names.
He looked at the thumbprints. There were forty in the folder. The ink had gone brown with age.
“Those are the parents,” she said. “The mothers, mostly. The fathers were at the courtyards.” She put the folder back. “Every one of them asked us the same question, and the question was: what will you do with it. And we said: we will tell you what we find. And then we did, for seven years, and then the funding stopped, and then we did not.”
She closed the box.
“September,” she said. “Enrol, and come back in September, and we will start with the ethics application. It will take a year. Do not expect anything to be fast.”
He enrolled in September. The notice board in the corridor had the new intake list on it, six names, and his was the fourth, and beside his name was the program: occupational and environmental health, doctoral, four years.
He stood in front of the board for a while. Then he took out his phone and called home.
His mother answered on the second ring.
“I have enrolled,” he said.
“At the medical college?”
“At the medical college. In Shantou.”
She was quiet. He could hear the rice cooker, and the fan, and his father’s cough somewhere in the next room, small, at the end of a breath.
“Then you will be two hours away instead of four,” she said.
“Two hours.”
“Good,” she said. “Then you can come home for the first and fifteenth.”
He said he could come home for the first and fifteenth.
“Have you eaten?” she said.
He said he had not.
“Then eat,” she said, and hung up. And he stood in the corridor with the phone in his hand and the notice board behind him and the sound of a lecture starting in the room at the end of the hall.