Chapter 2
A Brief Account of Victories
What follows is an account of victories in the old style. I take the form seriously. The great chroniclers kept such ledgers for emperors, and the genre requires only that the clerk record what was claimed and decline to record what was true, and I have tried to be faithful to both halves of that requirement.
The first victory concerns badges. The reader who has not worked in the technology industry will not know that the badge is the entire social system, so I must explain it, briefly, as one explains a suit of clothes to someone who has never been cold. In the Valley a full-time employee carries a badge of one color; a contractor carries another; a vendor a third. Everything else about the caste — the stock, the title, the chair that adjusts — is deniable. The badge is not. It is the one marker in that country that never lies, and it is clipped to the body at all times, in the manner of a tag on an exhibit.
Ying Ma held, at various points, all three colors. He never mentions the third. I have his badge photographs — the witness again — and in the last of them, 2022, the badge is turned backward, photograph to the chest, which is the posture of a man who has solved the badge problem the way our industry solves all problems: by hiding the evidence from himself. In the record he describes this period as “consulting.” The witness describes it as a staffing agency, the industry term for which is staff augmentation, and I pass both descriptions on without preference. The badge photographs, in which the lanyard of the third color is visible under his chin in every frame, settle the question of which description the photographs prefer.
The second victory concerns the question. The reader will by now anticipate its form: where are you really from. It was put to him, by my count across four thousand posts and one deposition of the witness, at least two hundred times, in lobbies, in elevators, on the N-Judah, at a wedding in Walnut Creek, once by a dentist mid-procedure. His standard answer evolved over the years, and I document the evolution because it is the clearest instrument in the record for measuring the man. In the early period he answered the question literally: “Fresno,” he would say, on the advice no one ever found, because he had never been to Fresno, and the answer bought him a small laugh and a larger confusion, and he counted both as wins. In the middle period he answered historically: five thousand years of continuous civilization, the four great inventions, the only ancient tongue still written in its original script. The witness recalls a dinner where this answer ran four minutes and ended, as it always ended, with the guest of honor — a man from Hangzhou who had heard the lecture in Mandarin as a child — excused to refill a drink that was already full. In the late period he stopped answering and posted instead about Rome. In my judgment the first was the only honest one, since it was the only one delivered in the knowledge that it was false.
The third victory is the follower-count contest, and I must treat it with care, because it is the one defeat in the entire record that the method could not process, and I will return to its mechanism in a moment. I set the scene with the industry’s own units, since no other units are admissible: the two men did not know each other’s work, had never shared a room, and could not have recognized each other’s voices. They knew each other’s numbers.
His opponent in this contest I will call Whiskers Wang, which is not his name. Whiskers Wang was a growth engineer at a company adjacent to his own, a mainland graduate of the second wave, and the two men had been circling each other on the timeline for a year in the way that two people with one follower in common circle each other, politely, with escalation. The contest began, as such contests do, over nothing: a thread about hiring bars, a reply, a subreply, and then Whiskers Wang posted a screenshot of his own profile. One hundred and twelve thousand followers. Ying Ma had four thousand two hundred, of which, the witness estimates, six hundred were bought during a Miami weekend whose invoices survive.
Here is where I must be exact. A man of the old school, losing such a contest, would have gone quiet, and quiet would have been recoverable. Ying Ma did something worse: he replied to the screenshot with his own arguments. He posted that followers were an imperial metric, that reach was curated by an algorithm with known biases, that Whiskers Wang’s numbers were inflated by engagement pods — and then, forty minutes later, he posted the number itself, his own four thousand two hundred, framed by the sentence “real ones know real ones.” The reply that ended the exchange came from an account with an egg for an avatar and has been liked, at my last check, eleven thousand times. It reads, in full: “bro thinks he’s in a reading contest.” Whiskers Wang’s own contribution to the exchange was a single character — 赢 — which needs no translation for anyone except the man it was addressed to, and which remains, at my last check, the only thing Whiskers Wang has ever said to him.
I want to be clear about what happened next, because the chapters that follow depend on it. A defeat in an argument can be filed. A defeat in romance can be reframed. But the follower-count contest was a defeat in a contest he had entered to prove a quantity — a number against a number, loser concedes the number — and the number was now public and permanent, screenshotted, archived, quoted back to him for the next two years by strangers. The method has an answer for everything except arithmetic. He did not post for nine days. The witness, who has kept the timeline, confirms the nine days and adds that on the tenth day Ying Ma returned with a thread about how the Roman legions slept, which is to say, he returned the way a man returns from a funeral, having decided to speak about something else. I said I would return to the mechanism of this defeat, and I will, in the next chapter; but I will say now that the nine days are the only period in the record during which the method is visible doing nothing, an engine with the load taken off it, idling.
Alongside the badges, the other Notes app kept its own ledger, and one entry deserves quotation in full, because it is the document in which the man and the method are closest together. The app is titled “Rejections, Explained,” and it contains, as of the last date I could open it, forty-one items. I reproduce the thirtieth entire, exactly as he filed it:
“Google — phone screen, SRE — Jan 2020. 45 min. Interviewer [name on file] had an accent, hard to follow, spent 10 min on ‘behavioral.’ Didn’t ask a single system design q. Verdict: ‘not a culture fit.’ Noted.
Conclusion: they only hire Stanfords now. Also: accent. Also: SRE is a dead end anyway (see 12/2019, Meta).
Lesson: my market is elsewhere.”
The lesson is filed under lessons, where lessons go. I have checked the December 2019 entry it cites, and this one. Both interviews were conducted in English, by interviewers whose names the entries preserve and I will not print and whose accents, so far as the record can establish, were those of two men born in San Jose and Seoul respectively. The Seoul-born interviewer was, I confirmed with some trouble, a graduate of San Jose State. The entry does not mention this. The entry has never been edited. That is the part I return to: he kept the rejections in an app titled “Explained,” and the explanations were written the night of each rejection, at the pressure of the hour, and were never once revised in daylight, and the file grew to forty-one entries at the same pressure, each note a small absolution, exit in ninety seconds, change nothing. Nine of the forty-one entries have no “Lesson:” line. The ninth of the nine is the last entry in the app, dated August 2021, and its lesson line is blank. I will take the chapters to get there.
The fourth victory concerns the subscription, and here the biographer’s problem is that the thing was never once named by anyone, including its holder, and must therefore be reconstructed from receipts. I have the receipts.
Receipt one, the pass: at a company offsite in Tahoe, in the summer of 2020, a senior product manager named Ross told Ying Ma, in the hot tub, within earshot of the witness, “you’re honestly the whitest Asian I know.” The witness reports that Ying Ma thanked him. Not laughed — thanked. The sentence was entered into the Notes app titled “Good Feedback” the same night, between a performance review from 2019 and a screenshot of a customer email, and I have seen the entry; it is filed under a heading Ross did not use and could not have intended: VALIDATION.
Receipt two, the revocation: four months later, in a strategy meeting at the same company, the founder — who is not a villain in this record and must not be drawn as one — turned to Ying Ma and said, “Ying, you’re our China guy. What’s your read?” I have the minutes. The witness was present. The question was, on its face, a compliment: the founder was asking the assembled engineers to treat Ying Ma as an authority. And the witness’s account of what followed is the most precise document in my possession. Ying Ma gave a read. The read was competent. The meeting moved on. Nothing was said, and everything was filed: the subscription, purchased in a hot tub in Tahoe, had been revoked in a conference room in San Mateo in a single sentence of four words, and the sentence had been spoken by a white man, which is the only reason it counted. Across the table, a mainland engineer named Wang — who will return in this record — wrote something in his notebook, showed it to his neighbor, and put it away. The witness could not read the characters and cannot now recall them. That night Ying Ma posted, for the first time, about the importance of Asian representation in leadership. He deleted it by morning. The deletion is on the record; the post itself I have never located, and I have looked. The likely objection, which is the biographer’s own: that a competent read is not nothing. It is not. But the meeting did not hear a competent read; it heard a China guy, and the difference between those two things is the distance between the man and the record, measured in one sentence, and the record is where he lived.
Receipt three, the reframe, filed out of order because he filed it out of order: the N-Judah, March of 2020, the first of the three receipts in date and the last in his ledger. On the N-Judah, a man told Ying Ma to go back to China. I will not enlarge the man; he was a man of the kind the city produces in quantity, unwell, loud, and the incident lasted the length of one stop. What belongs in the ledger is the processing. Ying Ma’s first feeling, he later explained to the group chat, was not fear but irritation at the clerical error: the man had misfiled him. He did not say “I’m from here,” which would have confirmed the category; he said, with great precision, “I’m not Chinese, I’m American,” and the man, who was not interested in paperwork, repeated himself at closer range. Ying Ma got off three stops early and walked the rest of the way to the shop, and composed on the walk a post about the CCP — not about the man, who did not matter, but about the regime, which would show everyone once and for all where he stood, which had always been the point of him. The post did numbers, by the standards of his account. His mother learned of the incident the following Sunday at the counter, from a customer, in Toishanese, and asked him about it in front of the plastic table, and he understood every word and answered in English, “It was nothing,” and the customer, an old woman from the block, looked at him for a moment and then told his mother, in Toishanese, that the boy was afraid to ride the bus. This was said ten feet away. It is the only diagnostic in the entire record that I regard as fully reliable. I note, and the note belongs here, that the incident was relayed to the group chat that evening by a mainland engineer named Wu Yawen, in a single line — 有人对他说 go back to China — and that his reply to her was his longest of the month. She did not reply to the reply. Her silence is on the record too.
I close the ledger with the fifth victory, which is also the entry that explains the whole system, and which I place last because the old chroniclers place the key last, where the hasty reader will not find it. It concerns contempt, and its direction.
In the period under review, Ying Ma held contempt for the following parties, all documented: the mainland engineers at his company, for their English and their group-bought condominiums; the WeChat-rich international students, for their money, which had arrived without being earned in the Valley’s manner; the unassimilated Cantonese of the Outer Sunset — his own customers, the people for whom his family had built its one institution — for their accents, their plastic bags, their haggling over seventy-five cents; the city of San Jose, for not being Palo Alto; the city of Palo Alto, for not being the city it thought it was; Ross, for the word “honestly”; Whiskers Wang, for the egg avatar; his father, for the two hundred words; the boba shop, for raising its price to $2.75. The list contains everyone he had ever met, and it also contains, as he did not notice, the one consistent rule of inclusion: whoever was below him was contemptible, and the ranking below him was revised hourly, by the only clerk the method ever trusted, who was also the only clerk it ever fooled.
There is no sixth entry. The ledger for this period closes with a receipt, in the merchant’s format: 2017–2019, two years and some months, one badge of the first color, one spreadsheet titled SOMEDAY, four thousand two hundred followers, and a POS system in a shop on Irving Street that does not crash, and which is not, by the rules of the old style, a victory at all — because no one was watching, and a victory, the old chroniclers knew, requires a crowd.