The True Story of Ying Ma
☰

Chapter 5

The Livelihood Problem

The chapter that follows was, at the outset, the one I expected to write last and fastest, on the assumption that a life with no job in it is a life with no documents in it. I record the assumption because I was wrong, and the shape of the wrongness is the chapter. The gig economy is the most documented labor arrangement in the history of work. It generates a receipt for every mile, a rating for every delivery, a heat map of the city’s hungers updated by the minute, and it does all this while paying, in the period under review, an hourly wage that after expenses the receipts themselves demolish. Ying Ma spent the autumn of 2021 inside that machine. The machine has more to say about him than any of his platforms did, and it is all arithmetic, and none of it is his.

The resignation has already been entered; the post survives in two drafts; the blank lesson line in the other ledger has been noted. What the record adds here is the reply of Wu Yawen — 恭喜, 保重 — and then nothing. I looked, in the months I spent on this chapter, for any further exchange between them, in the group chat, in the comments, in the apps where such things are stored by the companies that own them. There is none. The word 保重 was the last thing she wrote him, and it is the only entry in this entire account I have come to think of as a mercy: it is an instruction, and instructions can be followed, and there is no evidence he read it as one.

His own account of the autumn is the thread from August 15, four posts, titled “Building in public,” which announced a project — the name changed three times across the four posts, and the project, so far as I could establish from the repository the posts linked to, which was taken private at some point I cannot date, consisted of a landing page and a waitlist form. The waitlist form is still up. I submitted my own address to it in the spring, as research, and can report that the confirmation email never arrived, and that the form’s counter read 2,847 subscribers the day I found it and 2,847 the day I filed this chapter. I have chosen to believe that at least one of those numbers, at some point in the intervening years, was true.

The DoorDash work began in September, per the app’s own welcome email, which the witness — having never seen the man deliver anything — printed and left in my mailbox, supplied the way neighbors supply obituaries, from the outside. The app’s records, which the company shares with no one and which I reconstruct from the weekly summaries he screenshotted for a spreadsheet titled PROGRESS, give a picture I will render in the clerk’s grammar. He worked, most weeks, four nights. He averaged, per his own annotations, $11.40 an hour before gas, an annotation appended to a screenshot of the app’s own congratulatory banner — “You’re in the top 10% of Dashers this week!” — which he filed under the heading in the Good Feedback app, the other app, the twin: MORE PROOF.

The deliveries that matter to this record are the ones into SoMa. The reader who has followed the geography so far will not need the address explained. Reconify’s building stands on a block where the lunch trade is dense and the dinner trade is dying, and the app, which is blind to biography, sent him there eleven times between October and December, to a building he had entered for two years by the badge door, the last of them on the eleventh of December, a Friday, to the fourth floor, which was by then a different company, and I have the building’s directory from a broker’s listing to prove it. He was, per the app’s summary, tipped $3.00, by a man whose name the record does not preserve and whose face he photographed at the door, for proof of handoff, which is the industry’s term, and which is also, I have come to think, the whole method’s.

I want to be exact about what the man himself said, because the man himself said little that survived. There is one post from the period, November, and it reads in full: “Anyone else notice the economy has two speeds? 🏛️” It drew, at my last count, two hundred and eleven likes — a good day, by the standards of the four thousand two hundred — and I pass the number on without commentary, since the commentary it invites is the one the post itself declines: that the economy did indeed have two speeds, and that he was living in the fast one and delivering into the slow one, and that the joke’s second meaning was visible from the outside of the sentence but not from the desk where it was typed, which was the passenger seat of a 2012 Corolla, registered, per the DMV’s public records, to the shop.

The Sunday customer at the counter is the last document, and I set it down with the care the last document deserves. The witness who sits at the plastic table — the same witness, the only one, whose appearances in this record have all been at that table or in the three rooms of the subscription — reports a Sunday in November when Ying Ma came in at the lunch rush, in the red polo the app issues its top decile, and took orders for two hours when the counter fell behind, and the father did not ask and the mother did not say, and the regulars assumed, correctly, that the son was helping the family, and one of them said so, in Cantonese, to the mother: 好仔,帮家里. The mother agreed that it was so. Ying Ma was at the plastic table by then, on his phone, accepting an order. The order was a duck rice plate from a restaurant nine blocks south, for a man who had, the witness happened to know, eaten at the counter every Sunday for six years. The duck rice plate was the shop’s own dish. The app does not record what the delivery was called. At the counter it is called, in both languages, the same thing it has been called since before he was born. The PROGRESS spreadsheet’s last row is dated the twentieth of December, and its final column, which every prior row had filled with a dollar figure, contains one word, typed in the cell meant for numbers: MIAMI. The witness did not see the spreadsheet and cannot confirm the word, and I include it on the strength of the file alone, with the note that the file is the one document of that season on which no second opinion was ever needed, because it was typed by the only clerk the method ever trusted.