Chapter 6
From Revival to Decline
Miami begins, in the record, with a tan. The witness — whose appearances are governed by the rules of this account and who therefore did not see the tan — reports it the only way it traveled, which was by photograph: a selfie taken at the airport, posted on the twenty-fifth of January, 2022, captioned “New city. Same mission. 🏛️,” and the tan in it was, per three independent observers whose accounts I obtained, real, and expensive to maintain, and the first thing about him that Miami ever saw. What Miami saw second was the handle. @duckmaestro had been registered in December, before the flight was booked, which dates the decision to the twelfth of December or earlier, which is to say: the spreadsheet’s last row and the handle and the tan were one decision, made in the passenger seat of the Corolla in the week after the duck rice plate, and Miami was not the market being hot. Miami was the market being somewhere else.
The employer was an NFT studio, and I use the word employer with the looseness the period demands. The company’s LinkedIn page, which I have preserved, described it as “a venture studio producing utility-backed digital collectibles at the intersection of art, community, and apocalypse-proof value,” and its actual product was ten thousand ducks, procedurally generated from a trait table by a contractor in Eastern Europe, each with a numbered claim on a treasury that the white paper, forty-one pages of it, described as “community-governed.” His title was Head of Product. The studio had no product manager under him, and no product in the ordinary sense, and its head count, per the Florida registration I pulled, was six, of whom four are also in this record only as usernames.
The ducks themselves I must describe, because the period will not be believed otherwise. They were cartoon ducks, generated in the visual grammar of clip art, wearing — per the trait table, which survives — baseball caps, wizard hats, gas masks, and, in nine cases, the porcelain white wig of an eighteenth-century European aristocrat. Each duck had a rarity score computed by an algorithm the community then spent four months arguing was rigged. Nine thousand four hundred of the ten thousand went unsold. One duck, the two hundred and twenty-second, a duck in the white wig holding what the metadata calls a golden scepter, traded at the peak, in February, for three ETH, which was then — I have converted it at the rate of the day, as the clerk must — some eight thousand four hundred dollars, and Ying Ma quoted the number so often, in so many venues, for so long after the market that produced it had stopped existing, that the witness’s group chat gave the quote a name, and the name was “the 3,” and it outlived the studio, the treasury, and the chain the ducks were minted on.
His Miami life is documented at the edges the way the arrangement was: by the outside of documents. I know from the studio’s Discord, of which I was lent a read-only archive by a member who asked not to be named and whose own portfolio I will not discuss, that Ying Ma’s handle held the “product-philosophy” channel open through the spring with posts of a coherence the channel had not previously required — threads on “roadmap as myth,” on “community as the true smart contract” — and I know from the same archive the date the posts stopped, which was the ninth of May, and I know from the blockchain, which is one vast public receipt and the only honest book the period produced, what happened to the treasury in the week before the ninth of May. It was drained by its own governors, per the contract’s rules — legally, which is to say, in this industry, the same as secretly. The white wig duck’s buyer posted once about it afterward, in a forum I located: “down bad.” The duck itself still exists. It is owned, at my last check, by a wallet that has never transacted again, and I confess I find the duck’s silence more dignified than most of the speech this book records.
He returned to San Francisco tanned, and the tan was the document Miami issued him, and for eleven weeks it worked. This is the part of the chapter the old chroniclers would call the revival, and the term fits: the revival of a man who had spent the autumn delivering food into his former office was briefly, in certain rooms, a founder. The rooms were the ones the tan opened. I have the party listings — two launch events at warehouses on the water, a “founders dinner” at a restaurant on Bryant Street that charged, per the menu I photographed, ninety-five dollars for a tasting — and at each of them, per the witness, who was present at none of them but was shown, within the week, the same three photographs taken at all of them, Ying Ma was photographed holding a glass, and in each photograph he is the only man in the frame looking slightly to the left of the camera, at a point in the middle distance where, I have concluded after long study of these photographs, the future was supposed to be.
What he said about Miami, after: that he had run product at scale for a venture-backed studio; that the market had cooled for everyone; that he had “gotten out early.” The mutations are the familiar instrument, and I score them as before. In March, per the group chat: “we were doing nine figures of volume.” In June, per the same chat, answering a question about the ducks: “the ducks were never the point, the community was.” In September, on the timeline: “I left Miami before Miami left.” And in November, the final form, entered in Good Feedback under a heading I will let stand without translation: VISION.
I record the collapse of the fascination with the date the record gives, which is not the date of any event, because the collapse had no event. The treasury froze; the studio’s site went to a landing page with a Discord link; the Discord link died. And the fascination — the rooms, the glasses, the middle distance — did not end when the money did. It ended three weeks later, at a dinner the witness heard about the way offices hear — which is to say completely — at which a man with a checkmark asked Ying Ma what he was building now, and Ying Ma said, “the ducks were never the point, the community was,” and the man with the checkmark said, “right, but what are you building,” and the witness reports that Ying Ma answered, and that the answer was coherent, and that the man with the checkmark had already turned to someone else by the second sentence, and that the turning was not cruelty. It was the market. The market had spoken in its own language, attention, and what it had said was the thing the app had been saying all autumn in its own language, arithmetic: that he was worth, at current rates, exactly what he had been worth in December, before Miami, which is to say the tan had appreciated and he had not, and the tan faded, per the photographs, which continued through the winter, more slowly than the fascination, and neither, per the record, was renewed.