Chapter 7
Revolution
There is a question the record forces, and I will put it plainly and then spend a chapter declining to answer it the obvious way. Every movement of the period passed through San Francisco. The market had waves — web3, then the reconciliation of the ruin of web3 with the word community, then the machines — and each wave recruited in this city, funded in this city, and held its panels in this city, and Ying Ma was present, by the record’s own evidence, at the founding moment of each. He was in the rooms. He joined early. And he was, in every case, on the far side of the rope line within a season, holding the lanyard of a volunteer while the donors went through the door with the badges. The obvious answer is that he joined for the spoils. The record supports it. The record is also, as this book has established, made of his own sentences, and his own sentences never once say so. I will set down what he did, and the reader may keep the obvious answer or check it against the pattern, which is the only instrument I have.
The first wave: web3, 2021–22, already behind him by the previous chapter’s accounting, but it must be entered here because he entered it twice. He was, per the Discord archive, an early moderator of a DAO — community-governed, treasury-holding, meeting on Thursdays — and he was removed from the moderation desk in March of 2022 by a proposal, the fourth ever passed by that body, titled “Moderation Refresh.” He voted for it. I have the vote, from the chain, which keeps even this. The proposal’s author was a wallet that had joined the DAO in February and held, by the token weight that decided it, more of the DAO than the next nine wallets together. The DAO’s channel where the vote was discussed contained, on the day of the proposal, one message from his handle: “love the energy here, excited for what’s next 🏛️.” It is the only time in this record that he voted for his own exclusion, and I have searched the archive twice for a private explanation and found none, and the search is the chapter.
The second wave arrived wearing black. In the summer of 2020 the neighborhood councils and the coalitions had posted black squares, and by 2021 the squares were a genre, and when the wave of anti-Asian violence put the neighborhood orgs on the news, they reopened their membership forms, and Ying Ma filled one out. The org’s name — I preserve it as the record preserves it, because the name is the joke’s mechanism — was the Outer Sunset Family Assistance Network, and its filing history, which I read at the state’s business portal, was long and unbureaucratic: it had been a mutual-aid association since before his parents arrived, it had run a food pantry through the pandemic with the shops of Irving Street as donors, and its membership list was, per everything about it, a list of the aunties and uncles of the blocks it served. His application was processed by email in four days and approved without comment. What the org then asked of its members, per its newsletter, which I have in full: show up to the elder escort shifts, two hours a month, or pay the twenty-dollar dues, or both. He paid the dues. The newsletter’s escort roster for the following quarter, which a member gave me with the member’s permission, has forty-one names on it, and his is not one of them. He joined the revolution and paid for it in the only currency it was asking for, and I do not know why, and I will not pretend to, and the roster is the document I return to whenever this book threatens to become a case.
What he said publicly, in the same season, was the movement’s language at its most fluent. The quote-tweets from the Atlanta spring had established the posture — grief declined as weaponization — and the winter of 2022 matured it into a persona the timeline recognized: the Asian man who stood against hate without being a case of it, who posted the statistics with the temple emoji and the commentary without the first person. The posts did numbers. The movement’s actual organizations did not, per their own annual reports, which list, in the one I checked, an engagement rate of one-tenth of one percent and a donor base whose median gift was eleven dollars, and the distance between his numbers and theirs is the distance the whole period lived.
The third wave was the machines, and the machines were his last revolution, and the record of his membership in it is one panel. The panel was at a conference in the spring of 2023, “The Future of Work in the Age of Intelligence,” and it had five chairs and a moderator, and the moderator was a man with a checkmark and a podcast, and the four other chairs were held, per the conference site’s archived page, by two founders, a professor, and a person whose title was Chief Human Officer of the Future. Ying Ma was not on the panel. Ying Ma was in the audience, in the fourth row, and this document survives because he posted a photograph of his own name tag from the fourth row, with the caption “great panel incoming,” and the name tag, which the conference printed for all attendees in the same font, read YING MA — ATTENDEE, and I submit the name tag as the period’s whole self-portrait in one object: his name, in the right place on the badge, with the wrong word after it, photographed and posted as if the word did not matter, and eleven hundred likes, and one reply, from a stranger: “thoughts on the panel?”
The rope line’s final form was Kevin Zhao’s, and Kevin Zhao’s has been waiting since Chapter 2. Kevin had, by 2022, done the thing the record said he would: Stanford into stripe into his own fund into the AANHPI Founders Coalition, an organization whose launch, in September of 2022, was covered by a newsletter I subscribe to so that this book could quote it. The Coalition’s launch event was at a gallery on Minnesota Street, and its program, archived, lists the founder’s welcome, a keynote, a panel of four, and at the bottom, in a font one size smaller than the sponsors: “Community volunteers: K. Zhao, coord.” — and then, per the account the witness gave me secondhand, having heard it from a colleague who was there, a folding table by the door with lanyards. The account of the encounter is brief. Ying Ma arrived at the table as a guest and left it as a volunteer, and the difference was executed by Kevin Zhao with one sentence, delivered, per that account, with the smile the period used instead of doors: “We need hands like yours, brother.” The lanyard was blue. The donors’ badges were laminated. Ying Ma wore the lanyard for the duration of the event, and per the same account he wore it well, and he directed three guests to the coat room and one to the bar, and he was never once given the microphone, and the microphone was six feet away for two hours.
What the record shows, across the three waves, is a man who joined every revolution at the door and was stopped at the door of every revolution, and the stopping was done, each time, by the revolution’s own documents: a proposal he voted for, a roster he never signed, a badge with the wrong word. The old chroniclers, who are my authority for the shape of this chapter, had a sentence for the man who is barred from the rebellion that he arrived early for, and the sentence is not printable in a family chronicle, and its sense is: no. The movements said no in four dialects, and he heard none of them, because each dialect was the voice of a checkmark or a treasury or a roster, and those voices had never once, in his life, said no to him in English, and he had no ears at all for the language they said it in, which was, in every case, the language of the counter, the plastic table, the shop: the language of things that are true whether or not they are posted.