Chapter 16
Chapter Sixteen
37. Male. Age 8. Village 3. Blood lead, venous: 16.4 µg/dL. — appendix table, cohort survey, 2004
The library closed at eleven and the twenty-four-hour reading room opened at eleven, and the twenty-four-hour reading room was a different room, smaller. On the ground floor, with eight lamps and four terminals and a coffee machine that took one-yuan coins.
He found it in the second year, in the third month, on a Tuesday. He had gone in to look up a reference for a lab report and had stayed until two in the morning looking at something else.
The something else was the town.
He had lived in it for eighteen years and had never once typed its name into a search box. He typed it now, two characters, and pressed enter.
Nine hundred and forty-one results.
He read the titles. Blood lead. Dust. Dioxin. Hair. Placenta. Umbilical cord. Hearing. Temperament. Lung function. DNA damage. Birth weight. Stillbirth.
He sat back. The lamp above him hummed, green-shaded, the same green as the lamps in the big reading room. Somebody at the far end turned a page.
The reading room was cold at night. The air conditioning ran on a timer nobody had reset, and at one in the morning it came on and blew cold air down the back of his neck. And he put his jacket on without taking his eyes off the screen. His hands got cold first. Then his feet.
He had known. Everyone in the lane had known, the way they knew the weather: that it was bad, that nothing could be done, that you did not stand in it.
This was knowing with a table.
The first paper he opened was in English, in a journal called Environmental Health Perspectives, by Huo and others, 2007. Guiyu, an electronic waste recycling town.
He read the abstract twice. Two hundred and twenty-six children under six. One hundred and sixty-five from four villages in Guiyu, sixty-one from Chendian. Venous blood, taken at village kindergartens. Mean blood lead in Guiyu: 15.3 micrograms per deciliter. In Chendian: 9.9.
Eighty-one point eight per cent of Guiyu children were above ten.
He looked at that number for a while. Ten was the line. Ten was where the line had been drawn then, and the paper said the line was too high. And eighty-one point eight per cent of the children he had grown up with had been over it.
He thought of Class Six. Fifty-nine desks in a room built for sixty. The boy who could not sit still. The girl who read with her finger under the words. The two who were always last to the water fountain.
He had been one of the quiet ones. Quiet was not slow. But from the front of a classroom the two looked alike, and he had spent eleven years being looked at from the front of a classroom.
At one in the morning he found the theses.
The Chinese thesis database had two hundred and eleven results for the town, most of them from Shantou University Medical College, most of them master’s degrees, most of them with appendices.
He opened one from 2008. The title was something about blood lead and physical development in children from an electronic waste area. One hundred and eight pages. Chapter four was the data.
The appendix began on page ninety-four.
He scrolled to it and the table filled the screen: subject number, sex, age, village, blood lead. Row after row after row.
He scrolled to row thirty-seven.
Thirty-seven. Male. Eight. Village three. Sixteen point four.
He sat still.
The village was his village. The sex was his. The age was his age in 2004, the year the survey had been done, the year the white minibus had come into the lane and the nurses had set out twelve little white chairs.
Sixteen point four was the number on the slip.
He had never seen the slip. His mother had taken the envelope at the gate and folded it in thirds and put it in her fist and walked home talking about garlic shoots. He had heard the drawer open that night and shut again. He had never asked. Nobody in the lane had ever asked, because asking was not a thing you could do with a number, and the number was not for the children anyway.
The methods section was the part he read three times.
Venous blood, six millilitres, taken by trained nurses at the village kindergartens. Lead-free tubes. Stored at minus twenty. Analysed by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry, a Shimadzu AA-660 with a GFA-4B furnace and an ACS-60G autosampler. Wavelength 283.3 nanometres. Drying at 150 degrees, ashing at 325, atomisation at 1,400. Spike recoveries between 95 and 107 per cent.
He knew that machine. Not that one, but the type—there had been one in the second-year teaching lab, older, with a burnt-out lamp that the technician had replaced twice. He had run his own samples through it in October, four of them, diluted, and had got a curve.
Somebody had run children’s blood through a machine like that, in a room somewhere in Shantou, in 2004, and written down the numbers, and published them. The numbers had gone into a table, the table into an appendix, the appendix into a thesis, and the thesis into a database. And the database had come up on his screen at two in the morning because he had typed two characters and pressed enter.
That was the whole distance. Two characters.
The paper had a limitation section. He read it as carefully as the methods. Sample size. Single time point. No control for nutrition, for iron status, for the distance from the house to the nearest workshop. The authors wrote that further study was needed, as authors do, and then the paper ended, and the children in the table went back to being rows.
At three the night cleaner came through with her cart and emptied the bins and said nothing. There was one other student in the room, a girl at the far terminal with her head down on her arms, asleep or crying.
He got up and went to the water machine and drank a paper cup of cold water. The window was black and his face was in it, white from the screen. And behind his face the reading room went on with its eight lamps and its four terminals and its sleeping girl. Then he went back and sat down and read the second thesis.
The second thesis had a different sample: ninety-four children, one village, 2006, mean 14.7. The numbering restarted in every study, so there was no row thirty-seven to find.
He understood then that he would need the original logbooks. Not the published tables—the books the nurses had written in at the tables in the village kindergartens, with names and notes in the margins.
Those would be in a filing cabinet in Shantou, if they still existed.
He did not sleep. He went back at five and lay on the bed with his clothes on and watched the ceiling go from black to gray.
The roommate from Chaozhou got up at six-thirty and asked if he was sick. He said he had been reading all night.
The roommate looked at the printout on the desk, face down, and did not turn it over. “Was it interesting?”
“It was about my town.”
“Ah.” The roommate pulled on his shoes. “My town has a paper about it too. Nobody in my family has read it.”
He said nothing. The roommate said to eat something, and went out.
That summer he worked the trays knowing what the studies said.
It changed nothing about the work. The chips still came in stacks and went into bowls, and the thumbnail still read them, and the second lamp still burned. But he looked at the trays differently. Each tray was a quantity of a thing that had been measured in children.
He counted one afternoon and then stopped counting, because the counting was not the point, and the point was not countable in trays.
His mother noticed him looking. “What is it?”
“Nothing.”
“You are looking at the boards like they owe you money.”
He said they did not owe him anything.
She went back to her bowl and then said, without looking up: “The boards paid for your school. Do not look at them like that in this courtyard.”
He did not look at them like that again, in that courtyard.
He took the printout home in July, in the satchel’s front pocket, next to the pencil.
The bus was the same bus, four and a half yuan, the fish ponds, the water buffalo standing in them to their ears. He had the window seat. He took the page out once and looked at it.
- Male. Age 8. Village 3. 16.4.
He put it away before the bridge.
At home his mother asked what he had in the bag and he said books. She did not ask again. His father asked nothing at all, and sat at the bench with the scale, and coughed the small cough at the end of each breath, and drank his tea.
At night he took the page out in his room and put it in the drawer, under the letters, and did not tell anyone it was there.
The drawer already had the slip. He had never seen the slip, but the slip was in the drawer somewhere, folded in thirds, and now there was a page under the letters that said the same thing the slip said. And the two of them were in the same dark, and neither of them had a name on it.
He printed the page. The printer took coins, ten fen a page, and he had four, and the page came out warm and slightly curled. It smelled of toner and of the machine’s own heat, and he held it by the corner because the toner was still soft.
He read it once more under the lamp. Then he folded it in three and put it in his bag, in the pocket where the pencil went.
He did not know that it was his row. There had been boys of eight in village three. There had been four of them in Class Six alone, and the survey had taken children under six. And the arithmetic did not close neatly—if the survey was under six and he was eight, then the row could not be him.
He looked at the date on the thesis. It said the survey was conducted between 2004 and 2006 across three sampling rounds, and one round included children up to eight.
He read the sentence three times.
Then he sat with his hands flat on the desk and the lamp humming and the printout in his. bag, and did the arithmetic that he had been doing all his life, the arithmetic with two columns. Except that this time the column on the left was him and the column on the right was a number on a page.
At two he went out to the corridor and called home.
His mother answered on the fourth ring, which meant she had been asleep.
“What is it? Is it the money?”
He said it was not the money.
“Then why are you calling at this hour?”
He listened to her breathe. Behind her there was a fan, and the fridge, and the small dry sound of the phone being shifted from one ear to the other.
He said he had been reading about the town.
She was quiet a moment.
“Reading what about the town?”
“Papers. Studies. From the medical college in Shantou. They did surveys, in 2004. On the children.”
The fan turned. His mother did not say anything for a while.
“Your father is asleep,” she said at last. “Do not call about this at night. Call in the daytime, and do not say the word lead on the phone.”
He said he would not say the word.
“Did they find anything?” she said. “The studies. Did they find anything we did not know?”
He thought about the eighty-one point eight per cent. He thought about the six point nine IQ points. He thought about the row.
“They found what we knew,” he said. “They just found it with numbers.”
She was quiet again. Then she said: “Then it is a good thing somebody wrote it down. Nobody here wrote it down.”
She hung up first, the way she always did.
He did not go back to the dormitory. He went to the lab at six when the building opened and set up his bench and did the week’s titration, and his hands were steady. And the endpoint came out to the drop, and the teaching assistant looked at his numbers and said, “clean.”
He put the printout in the drawer of his desk in the dormitory, under the textbooks.
In the summer he took it home in the satchel’s front pocket, next to the pencil.
He looked at it on the bus, once, and then put it away.
Sixteen point four. Male. Eight. Village three.
He would keep the page for eight years. He did not know that yet. He only knew that he had found a number with a body under it, and the body was either his or one of four boys’. And in either case the number was the town’s, and the town had never once said it out loud.
The bus between campuses was the number 2, and it left the east gate every twenty minutes. And in winter it was dark at five and the bus was full of students with their heads down.
He rode it twice a week for a year. East campus for the chemistry, north campus for the public health lectures. Eleven minutes each way.
In the chemistry building the rooms were cold and white and smelled of solvent. In the public health building the rooms were warm and beige and smelled of paper, and the lectures were about people—about how you find them. How you follow them, how you keep them in a study for twenty years without losing half of them to the cities.
He sat in the back row of those lectures and took notes in the smallest characters he had one lecturer. An old man with a cracked voice, said that the hardest thing in epidemiology was not the statistics. It was the follow-up. You find a cohort, he said, and you measure them, and then you try to find them again in ten years. And half of them have gone to Shenzhen and the other half have changed their phone numbers, and the ones who stay are the ones who are sick.
He wrote that down and underlined it once.
Then he wrote, in the margin, in characters so small they were almost a line: the ones who stay.
He thought about the lane. He thought about who had stayed. His father had stayed. His mother had stayed. Ah-Ma had stayed. His cousin had stayed. Everyone who could go had gone, and everyone who had gone had sent money back, and the ones who stayed had spent it on the ones who were sick.
Five of them, in one house. Two of them were still there.
In the third year he changed his reading.
The environmental chemistry papers were about soil and water and dust. The public health papers were about people. He read both, and the two literatures did not talk to each. other, and the gap between them had a shape: the chemistry said what was in the ground, and the public health said what was in the blood. And nobody in either literature had followed a single child from the one to the other for twenty years.
He looked for that paper. He searched for cohort, for follow-up, for longitudinal, for twenty years, for Guiyu. He found three-year studies and five-year studies and one study that had followed children for seven years and stopped.
He wrote the question in the back of his notebook, in the smallest characters, and underlined it once:
What happened to them?
He did not underline it twice. Twice was for numbers that were right. This was a question, and questions were not right or wrong, they were only answered or not.
Then he closed the notebook and went out to the bus, which left every twenty minutes. The chemistry building was on the east side and the public health building was on the north side, and the two disciplines were one bus apart. The bus took eleven minutes, and he rode it twice a week for a year.